The killing of  Osama bin Laden, the  mastermind of 9 /11 , in a  ground operation carried out  exclusively by US troops on  late Sunday night near  Pakistan's military academy in  Abbottabad, could jeopardize  relations between  Islamabad   and Washington.  For hours,  Pakistan  kept mum  over the news of bin Laden's  death. It broke its silence  about 11  hours after the  incident when the country's  foreign office confirmed that  the operation against bin  Laden was entirely the  handiwork of the US forces.  The statement came after  long hours of deliberations  and brainstorming between  the country's top civilian and  military leadership in the  Pakistan president house at  Islamabad.  "In an intelligence driven  operation,  Osama bin Laden   was killed in the surroundings  of Abbottabad in the early  hours of this morning. This  operation was conducted by  the US forces in accordance  with declared US policy that  Osama bin Laden will be  eliminated in a direct action  by the US forces, wherever  found," Tehmina Janjua,  Pakistan's foreign office  spokesperson said.  Following Janjua's statement,  Pakistani PM Yusuf Raza Gilani called the killing of Osama bin Laden a great victory. "It is  Pakistan's stated policy not to  allow its soil for terrorist  attacks against any country.  Pakistan's political leadership,  parliament, state institutions  and the whole nation are fully  united in their resolve to  eliminate terrorism," Gilani  said, adding that he didn't  know the details of the US  operation.  Pakistan's military has not  released any statement about  bin laden's killing. Some  observers believe that  Pakistan would like to be seen as not having helped in this  operation because it would  become the immediate target  of the terrorist network.  However, Pakistan's former ISI  chief, General Hameed Gul,  said that Osama may have  been in Pakistan for  treatment. "Osama's presence  raises questions about the  Pakistan intelligence's ability," he said.  Gul was critical of US activities in Pakistan. "Americans have  been given a free hand in  Pakistan and they do whatever they want. They have  hoodwinked us and are after  Pakistan's nuclear assets."  He said there will be a  backlash from al-Qaida if it  transpires that Pakistan  helped the US in this  operation.  The death of bin Laden in  Abbottabad, a city mostly  dominated by Pakistan's  military, has raised many  questions regarding the role of Pakistan's Inter Services  Intelligence (ISI)whether his  whereabouts were known to  the spy agency. Bin Laden was  not living in an ordinary  residence. The walls of three- storey building were 12-  to  18 ft high, topped with barbed  wire. Access to the compound  was severely restricted. Bin  Laden's compound was  roughly eight times larger  than other houses in the area.  Since the start of the war on  terror, Pakistani leaders have  denied the presence of bin  Laden in the country. His  death on Sunday night caught  the Pakistani leadership  unawares. His presence just  next to the Kakul military  academy in Abbottabad which  produce scores of officers  every year for the Pakistan's  army came as a big surprise.  Contrary to frequent media/ intelligence speculation in the  last several years that Bin  Laden could be hiding in the  rugged tribal areas of Pakistan or even across the border in Afghanistan , the al-Qaida's  iconic leader was found in a  rather peaceful and scenic  suburb of Pakistan's capital,  Islamabad.  Sources inside Peshawar's US  consulate informed TOI that  the American officials working  in the north-western city were  suddenly told on Friday to  leave because of threats of  their abductions.  The killing of bin Laden came  as relations between the US  and Pakistan have reached to  its lowest point since the start  of the war against terror. Since 9 /11 , the US has given the  Pakistan's military nearly $20  billion for counter-terrorism  campaigns.  The US chairman of the  Joint  Chiefs of Staff , Admiral Mike  Mullen, during his last visit to  Islamabad, publicly criticized  Pakistan's military for not  acting against al-Qaida linked  insurgent groups sheltering in  Pakistan's tribal region of  North Waziristan.  However, last week Pakistan's  army chief, General Ashfaq  Pervez Kayani, told the  passing out parade of cadets  from the Kakul military  academy that Pakistan had  broken the back of terrorism in the country. The killing of bin  Laden within few hundred  metres distance from the  military academy has  evaporated Kiyani's tall claim  into thin air. 9 /11  mastermind Osama bin Laden dead.
Monday, May 2, 2011
In Pakistan, An Embarrassed Silance On Killing Of Bin Laden
Pakistan  faced  enormous embarrassment on  Monday after Osama bin  Laden was killed by U.S.  Special Forces, raising  questions over whether its  military and intelligence were  too incompetent to catch him  themselves or knew all along  where he was hiding. The killing of the world's most- wanted man in a house just a few  hundred meters from Pakistan's  version of the West Point military  academy will only fuel suspicions  that the country has been playing  a double-game over Islamist  militants and al Qaeda. Analysts say it would be a stretch  to believe Pakistan's spy agency  did not know bin Laden was living  in a town just a couple of hours up  the road from Islamabad: if it did  know, the country was essentially  caught red-handed shielding him  from capture. "There will be a lot of tension  between Washington and  Islamabad because bin Laden  seems to have been living here  close to Islamabad," said Imtiaz  Gul, a  Pakistani  security analyst. " This is a serious blow to the  credibility of Pakistan." SNARED BEHIND PAKISTAN'S BACK Washington has in the past  accused Pakistan of maintaining  ties to militants targeting U.S.  troops in neighboring  Afghanistan .  Relations soured further in recent  months over U.S. drone attacks and CIA activities in the country that  have fueled anti-American  sentiment. For years, however, Pakistan had  maintained it did not know bin  Laden's whereabouts, vowing that  if Washington had actionable  intelligence, its military and  security agencies would act on it. In October 2009 , Secretary of State Hillary Clinton voiced dismay that  bin Laden and other prominent  militants had not yet been caught  and suggested Pakistani  complicity, telling newspaper  editors in Lahore she found it " hard to believe that nobody in your government knows where they are  and couldn't get them if they really wanted to." Neither Pakistan's spy agency, the  Directorate of Inter-Services  Intelligence (ISI), nor its military  spokesmen returned repeated calls for comment on Monday. Adding to the silence, Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister  Yusuf Raza Gilani have said  nothing publicly about the  operation. Bin Laden was killed in a dramatic  night-time raid by U.S. helicopters  on his hideout in Abbottabad,  home to Pakistan's main military  academy. President Barack Obama, speaking  in a hastily announced late-night  news conference, said cooperation  from Pakistan had helped lead U.S. forces to bin Laden. But American  and Pakistani sources familiar with  details of the operation said U.S.  forces had snared bin Laden  virtually behind Pakistan's back. That the mastermind of the  September 11 , 2001 , attacks on  the United States was not hiding in mountains along the border but in  relative comfort in a town hosting  the main military school and home  to scores of officers will bolster  those who have long argued that  Pakistan has been playing a  duplicitous hand. "The evidence suggests it was  done totally by the Americans, and  the Pakistan military, they have  been informed at the 11 th hour,"  said Hassan Askari Rizvi, an  independent political analyst. "There is distrust between the two  intelligence agencies and ... this is  very similar to what the Americans  did when they fired missiles on  Osama's training camps in August  1998. " At that time, the United States  gave Islamabad just 90  minutes'  notice that it would retaliate for  two embassy bombings in Africa  because it was worried Pakistan  would tip off the Afghan Taliban,  who in turn could have warned bin  Laden. "This operation was  conducted by the U.S. forces in  accordance with the U.S. policy of  hunting down Osama wherever he  was supposed to be," said Wajid  Shamsul Hasan, Pakistan High  Commissioner to Britain, speaking  to Sky News. "They successfully  eliminated him and subsequently  they informed the president of  Pakistan this morning of the event. " BACKLASH POSSIBLE IN PAKISTAN Just how much the Pakistani  military knew of the raid on bin  Laden's mansion hideout is not  clear. For one thing, analysts say, it  would have been difficult for the U. S. Special Forces to act without  some logistical military assistance  on the ground. It is also possible that Pakistan  allowed the operation to go ahead  as part of a deal with Washington  on its stake in the endgame in  Afghanistan, where U.S. troops are  due to start withdrawing in July  after nearly 10  years of war. But the government and security  agencies had one strong reason for staying silent and letting  Washington take the credit for the  raid: fear of a public backlash for  working so closely with the United  States to nab a man who has in the past been popular in Pakistan. Hours after the assault, about 200  Islamists held a rally in the city of  Quetta in the southwestern  province of Baluchistan to  condemn the killing of bin Laden.  The protesters, from a small  Islamist party, chanted "down with  America," and "Long live Osama  bin Laden." "He was a great holy warrior," said  Mufti Kifayatullah, a lawmaker  from Jamiat-e-Ulema-e-Islam, a  hardline Islamic group, said while  speaking in the provincial  assembly in Peshawar. "Osama was the name of an ideology and an  ideology does not die with the  death of a person. Today was the  blackest day in the history of  Pakistan." Popular news anchors with alleged  ties to the spy agencies referred on air to bin Laden as a "shaheed," or  martyr. And Imran Khan, the cricketer- turned-populist-politician, said  Washington should immediately  end the war in Afghanistan  because Pakistan would pay the  price for bin Laden's death. "There will be a backlash from  supporters of Osama bin Laden,  who will think Pakistan has a role  in it, and secondly there will be a  pressure from America because of  the very fact that he (Laden) was  found in Pakistan," he told Geo TV.
BIN LADEN'S DEATH : What This Mean's For Pakistan ISI
When U.S. President Obama called  Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari  to tell him the news that Osama  bin Laden had been killed by U.S.  citizens in a lightening raid not far  from the Pakistani capital last  night, he also instructed his team  to similarly inform their Pakistani  counterparts. The question is, who  was surprised when they picked up  the phone? That bin Laden had been living in  a specially constructed compound  less than an hours' drive from  Pakistani military HQ, and in the  same town as the country's premier military academy, makes the near  constant denials by Pakistan's  intelligence agencies that the  terror group leader was in the  country difficult to swallow. Sure,  there are at times a Keystone-cops  element to the operational  methods of the agencies—those  assigned to trail foreign journalists in the country are less than subtle  in their surveillance methods: One  once asked me my address, as he  was sitting in my house, another  decided that quizzing my driver  about my activities was far less  work than actually following me to  interviews—but bumbling or not,  they are ubiquitous. The crackle  and click of telephone lines is the  constant reminder that no  conversation over the phone is  private, the crew-cut men in beige  that materialize whenever I start  asking questions proof that one is  never quite alone in Pakistan. So  the idea that absolutely no one but American intelligence knew who  was living in that multi-million  dollar compound beggars belief. Obama was careful to thank  Pakistani assistance in the raid, but how, exactly, the Pakistanis  assisted will be a key part of  understanding the relationship  between Pakistan and the U.S.  going forward. Just a few weeks  ago, U.S. Chairman of Joint Chiefs  of Staff Admiral Michael Mullen  told Pakistani English-language  newspaper Dawn that the  Directorate for Inter-Services  Intelligence (ISI) had a  “ relationship”  with the al Qaeda  affiliated Haqqani network: "It's fairly well known that the ISI  has a longstanding relationship  with the Haqqani network…. Haqqani is supporting, funding,  training fighters that are killing  Americans and killing coalition  partners. And I have a sacred  obligation to do all I can to make  sure that doesn't happen…..So that' s at the core - it's not the only  thing -- but that's at the core that I  think is the most difficult part of  the relationship.” The Haqqani network is thought to  be behind several gruesome  attacks on foreign soldiers and  embassies in neighboring  Afghanistan, including the 2009  attack on the Indian Embassy there that killed 17  and wounded 63.  More worryingly is recent evidence  that the ISI may have had links to  Lashkar-e-Taiba, the group behind  the 2008  terror attacks on Mumbai, in which 10  well-trained Pakistani  militants coordinated a bombing  and shooting attack at several  landmarks that killed 164.  At a trial slated for May 16 th  David Headley, the Pakistani American accused of  assisting LeT in reconnaissance for  the attack, is expected to implicate the ISI, confirming long held  suspicions by both American and  Indian authorities, as well as many  Pakistanis. Defenders of the ISI say that it is  their job to maintain contacts with  groups like that as part of their  intelligence gathering methods.  One spokesman told me that the  ISI has infiltrators in the terror  groups just like the FBI has people  undercover in the Mafia. That may  be the case. But either way the ISI  isn't going to come out of this well. Either they knew about bin Laden  and waited to inform the U.S., or  they were oblivious to the  presence of a massive, multi- million dollar compound in their  back yard, one so secretive that  the residents burned their own  trash. That doesn't augur well for  Pakistan's ability to tackle the next terrorist threat that comes out of  the woodwork.
Pakistan Faces Presuse After Osama Killed
Pakistan declared the killing of  Osama bin Laden a "major  setback" to global terrorism but it  will inevitably come under pressure to explain how the al Qaeda leader was holed up in a mansion near a  military facility. Bin Laden was killed in a dramatic  night-time raid by US helicopters  and troops on his hideout in  Abbottabad, a town that is home to a military academy and less than  two hours' drive from the Pakistani  capital, Islamabad. "Osama bin Laden's death  illustrates the resolve of the  international community, including Pakistan, to fight and eliminate  terrorism," the government said in  a statement. "It constitutes a major setback to terrorist organisations  around the world." However, it was not clear whether  the Pakistan military was involved  in the operation and there was no  official comment from the  government for several hours after the news of bin Laden's killing  broke, raising the possibility that  Islamabad was taken by surprise. That bin Laden, mastermind of the  September 11 , 2001 , attacks on  the United States, was not hiding  in mountains along the border but  in relative comfort near a military  academy will bolster those who  have long argued that Pakistan has been playing a duplicitous hand. Just 10  days ago Pakistan's army  chief addressed army cadets at  that very academy, saying the  country's military had broken the  back of militants linked to al  Qaeda and the Taliban. Washington has in the past  accused Pakistan of maintaining  ties to militants targeting U.S.  troops in neighboring Afghanistan.  Relations have soured in recent  months over U.S. drone attacks and CIA activities in the country. Pakistan's powerful intelligence  agency, the ISI, has long been  suspected of links to al Qaeda's  precursor, the Haqqani network,  cultivated during the 1980 s when  Jalaluddin Haqqani was a feared  battlefield commander against the  Soviet Union in Afghanistan. Pakistan's arch-rival, India, was  quick to comment, saying the news underlined its "concern that  terrorists belonging to different  organisations find sanctuary in  Pakistan." "For some time there will be a lot  of tension between Washington  and Islamabad because bin Laden  seems to have been living here  close to Islamabad," said Imtiaz  Gul, a Pakistani security analyst. "If the ISI had known, then  somebody within the ISI must have  leaked this information," Gul said.  "Pakistan will have to do a lot of  damage control because the  Americans have been reporting he  is in Pakistan ... this is a serious  blow to the credibility of Pakistan." FLAMES, GUNSHOTS, A BLAST Abbottabad is a popular summer  resort, located in a valley  surrounded by green hills near  Pakistani Kashmir. Islamist  militants, particularly those  fighting in Indian-controlled  Kashmir, used to have training  camps near the town. A Reuters reporter in the town on  Monday said bin Laden's single- storey residence stood fourth in a  row of about a dozen houses, a  satellite perched on the roof above a walled compound. A helicopter  covered by a sheet sat in a nearby  field. Mohammad Idrees, who lives  around 400  meters from the house, said local residents were woken in  the night by the sound of a big  explosion. "We rushed to the  rooftop and saw flames near that  house. We also heard some  gunshots," Idrees said. "Soon after  the blast, we saw military vehicles  rushing to the site of the blast." Another resident, Nasir Khan, said  that commandos had encircled the  compound as three helicopters  hovered overhead. "All of a sudden there was firing  toward the helicopters from the  ground," said Khan, who had  watched the drama unfold from his rooftop. "There was intense firing  and then I saw one of the  helicopters crash." A Pakistani military helicopter  crashed near Abbottabad on  Sunday night, killing one and  wounding two, according to local  media. It was unclear if the crash  was related to bin Laden's death,  but witnesses reported gunshots  and heavy firing before one of two  low-flying helicopters crashed near the academy. Sohaib Athar, whose profile says he is an IT consultant taking a break  from the ratrace by hiding in the  mountains, sent out a stream of  live updates on Twitter about the  movement of helicopters and  blasts without realizing it was a  raid on the world's most hunted  man. Some of his early tweets were: " Helicopter hovering above  Abbottabad at 1  am (rare event);  Go away helicopter - before I take  out my giant swatter." Then he reported his window  rattling and a bang. "I hope it's not the start of something nasty," he  tweeted. Soon after there were blasts. There were two helicopters, one of them  had gone down, Athar wrote.
A massive house with no telephone or internet connection led to bin Laden
  A large mansion in a massive compound with 12 feet to 18  feet tall walls topped with barbed wire. No telephone or internet  connection to the house. And seldom seen residents who burnt their trash  rather than dispose it as other neighbors did. 
These were the slender leads that eventually took US spooks and seals to the world's most wanted fugitive. Osama bin Laden lived not in a cave in some frontier mountain redoubt, but in a suburban neighborhood in a million-strong city just an hour's drive from Islamabad, right under the eyes of the Pakistani military.
No one is particularly surprised about this. In fact, going by the track record of major al-Qaida and Taliban operatives captured so far, it would seem that images of them hiding in caves are overblown. Most of them have been captured in Pakistani cities -- Khalid Shaikh Mohammed in Rawalpindi, Mullah Biradhar in Karachi, and other operatives in places like Faisalabad and Multan. It would seem the terrorists like their comfort -- or at least they are kept in comfort.
Details of how the US homed in on bin Laden are still sketchy, but this much is known based on what President Obama himself said and background briefings by officials.
Right from the moment he took office, Obama resolved to hunt down bin Laden, a goal that his predecessor Bush (who once suggested he did not want to personalize the bin Laden hunt) appeared to have taken his eyes off from. The new President called in the CIA chief and told him to devote whatever resources were needed to nail bin Laden, even as he shifted the focus from the war on Iraq to the Af-Pak theater.
Last August or September, the CIA team tasked with the bin Laden hunt succeeded in developing leads obtained from a Guantanamo detainee four years ago about two brothers who had acted as couriers for bin Laden. Their identity was established and then their coordinates.
Tracking then, the U.S team got to know with some degree of certainty that they were making sorties to a compound in Abbottabad, a military cantonment 60 kms north of Islamabad. The design of the compound and the mansion, and the activities surrounding it, indicated it held someone important.
Whether the US knew with certainty it was bid Laden is not clear, but between March 14 and April 28, President Obama held five national security meetings with his top aides to decide on how to approach the problem at a time ties with Pakistan were at all all-time low because of the Raymond Davis episode. The incident made it all the more dicey to employ American forces for an airborne attack, particularly given past U.S experience in Iran and Somalia, and the Pakistani military's virulent response to any suggestion of U.S ground action inside Pakistan, much less at the doors of a military cantonment.
Still, Obama gave the go-ahead for the operation over the weekend. Three or four U.S choppers carrying elite Navy Seals were deployed on Sunday night/Monday early a.m. No Pakistani personnel were involved.
The US team ran into resistance. Bin Laden was living in the compound with his eldest son and his youngest wife. The two couriers were also with him. Bin Laden was reportedly shot in the head in a firefight. Two other men and a woman also died. It's not clear if they included his son and wife.
There were other mishaps. A US chopper involved in the attack developed a malfunction at some point and crashed in the neighborhood. This was reported in the Pakistani media several hours before news of bin Laden's death emerged, with no mention of American involvement or the hunt for bin Laden. Pakistani officials had shut down the area and kept out the media on orders from the US.
Only in the morning in Pakistan, when the wreckage from the chopper (which the US reportedly destroyed) was cleared, did the story emerge that the smoldering house in the Abbotabad suburb had hosted Osama bin Laden. He has been shot and killed by US forces, who had even taken away his body from Pakistan.
These were the slender leads that eventually took US spooks and seals to the world's most wanted fugitive. Osama bin Laden lived not in a cave in some frontier mountain redoubt, but in a suburban neighborhood in a million-strong city just an hour's drive from Islamabad, right under the eyes of the Pakistani military.
No one is particularly surprised about this. In fact, going by the track record of major al-Qaida and Taliban operatives captured so far, it would seem that images of them hiding in caves are overblown. Most of them have been captured in Pakistani cities -- Khalid Shaikh Mohammed in Rawalpindi, Mullah Biradhar in Karachi, and other operatives in places like Faisalabad and Multan. It would seem the terrorists like their comfort -- or at least they are kept in comfort.
Details of how the US homed in on bin Laden are still sketchy, but this much is known based on what President Obama himself said and background briefings by officials.
Right from the moment he took office, Obama resolved to hunt down bin Laden, a goal that his predecessor Bush (who once suggested he did not want to personalize the bin Laden hunt) appeared to have taken his eyes off from. The new President called in the CIA chief and told him to devote whatever resources were needed to nail bin Laden, even as he shifted the focus from the war on Iraq to the Af-Pak theater.
Last August or September, the CIA team tasked with the bin Laden hunt succeeded in developing leads obtained from a Guantanamo detainee four years ago about two brothers who had acted as couriers for bin Laden. Their identity was established and then their coordinates.
Tracking then, the U.S team got to know with some degree of certainty that they were making sorties to a compound in Abbottabad, a military cantonment 60 kms north of Islamabad. The design of the compound and the mansion, and the activities surrounding it, indicated it held someone important.
Whether the US knew with certainty it was bid Laden is not clear, but between March 14 and April 28, President Obama held five national security meetings with his top aides to decide on how to approach the problem at a time ties with Pakistan were at all all-time low because of the Raymond Davis episode. The incident made it all the more dicey to employ American forces for an airborne attack, particularly given past U.S experience in Iran and Somalia, and the Pakistani military's virulent response to any suggestion of U.S ground action inside Pakistan, much less at the doors of a military cantonment.
Still, Obama gave the go-ahead for the operation over the weekend. Three or four U.S choppers carrying elite Navy Seals were deployed on Sunday night/Monday early a.m. No Pakistani personnel were involved.
The US team ran into resistance. Bin Laden was living in the compound with his eldest son and his youngest wife. The two couriers were also with him. Bin Laden was reportedly shot in the head in a firefight. Two other men and a woman also died. It's not clear if they included his son and wife.
There were other mishaps. A US chopper involved in the attack developed a malfunction at some point and crashed in the neighborhood. This was reported in the Pakistani media several hours before news of bin Laden's death emerged, with no mention of American involvement or the hunt for bin Laden. Pakistani officials had shut down the area and kept out the media on orders from the US.
Only in the morning in Pakistan, when the wreckage from the chopper (which the US reportedly destroyed) was cleared, did the story emerge that the smoldering house in the Abbotabad suburb had hosted Osama bin Laden. He has been shot and killed by US forces, who had even taken away his body from Pakistan.
Finger of suspicion at Pak military for protecting bin Laden
  The finger of suspicion is pointing squarely at the  Pakistani  military and intelligence for sheltering and protecting  Osama  bin Laden before US forces hunted him down and put a bullet in his  head on Sunday. The coordinates of the action and sequence of events  suggest that the al-Qaida fugitive may have been killed in an ISI  safehouse. 
Within hours of the news of bin Laden's killing, speculation raged about Pakistan and its spy agency's role in the momentous episode. President Obama made it clear that the operation to hunt down bin Laden was conducted exclusively by US forces -- ''a small team of Americans,'' he said -- at his direction. While he thanked Pakistan's civilian government for its help, naming President Zardari in particular, he made no mention of any other active Pakistani role, especially in the operation. It was "all-American" and "Made in USA," he seemed to say.
But in a glaring counter-narrative, Pakistani security officials claimed bin Laden was nailed in a joint operation between CIA and Pakistani forces. "It was carried out on a very precise info that some high-value target is there," one Pakistani official was quoted as saying.
US analysts uniformly suggested this was clearly aimed at ducking charges of the Pakistani military's possible role in hiding bin Laden. ''This is hugely embarrassing for Pakistan,'' was a common refrain on US TV channels throughout the night.
In fact, top US officials have openly suggested for months that the Pakistani military establishment was hiding bin Laden. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton came closest to publicly exposing Pakistan's role last May when she accused some government officials there of harboring Osama bin Laden and Mullah Omar.
''I am not saying they are at the highest level...but I believe somewhere in this government are people who know where Osama bin Laden and al-Qaida and where Mullah Omar and the leadership of the Taliban are,'' Clinton said on May 10 last year, adding, ''We expect more cooperation (from Pakistan) to help us bring to justice capture or kill those who brought us 9/11.''
Taken together with President Obama's pointed 'thank you' to President Zardari and leaving out any mention of Pakistani forces' involvement, it would seem that Washington believes that Pakistan's military intelligence establishment, including the ISI, was sheltering bin Laden. The ISI was accused as recently as last week by the top US military official Admiral Mike Mullen of having terrorist links, and named as a terrorist support entity by US officials, according to the Guantanamo cables.
Lending credence to the charges is the fact that US forces homed in on bin Laden in Abbottabad, which is a cantonment just 50 kms from Islamabad, where the Pakistani military has a strong presence. The place where bin Laden was killed is only kilometers from the Kakul military academy, where many Pakistani military elites, including some of its ISI cadres, graduate from.
While US officials are tightlipped about precise details, analysts are trying to figure out whether the compound that sheltered bin Laden was an ISI safehouse. There is also speculation as to whether Hillary Clinton was referring to this when she made her pointed remarks last May.
US officials have said for years that they believed bin Laden escaped to Pakistan after the American bombing campaign in Afghanistan. But Pakistani officials, including its former military ruler Pervez Musharraf, insisted that he was in Afghanistan, even as Afghan officials would angrily refute it and say he is in Pakistan. In the end, the Americans and Afghans were right on the money.
Within hours of the news of bin Laden's killing, speculation raged about Pakistan and its spy agency's role in the momentous episode. President Obama made it clear that the operation to hunt down bin Laden was conducted exclusively by US forces -- ''a small team of Americans,'' he said -- at his direction. While he thanked Pakistan's civilian government for its help, naming President Zardari in particular, he made no mention of any other active Pakistani role, especially in the operation. It was "all-American" and "Made in USA," he seemed to say.
But in a glaring counter-narrative, Pakistani security officials claimed bin Laden was nailed in a joint operation between CIA and Pakistani forces. "It was carried out on a very precise info that some high-value target is there," one Pakistani official was quoted as saying.
US analysts uniformly suggested this was clearly aimed at ducking charges of the Pakistani military's possible role in hiding bin Laden. ''This is hugely embarrassing for Pakistan,'' was a common refrain on US TV channels throughout the night.
In fact, top US officials have openly suggested for months that the Pakistani military establishment was hiding bin Laden. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton came closest to publicly exposing Pakistan's role last May when she accused some government officials there of harboring Osama bin Laden and Mullah Omar.
''I am not saying they are at the highest level...but I believe somewhere in this government are people who know where Osama bin Laden and al-Qaida and where Mullah Omar and the leadership of the Taliban are,'' Clinton said on May 10 last year, adding, ''We expect more cooperation (from Pakistan) to help us bring to justice capture or kill those who brought us 9/11.''
Taken together with President Obama's pointed 'thank you' to President Zardari and leaving out any mention of Pakistani forces' involvement, it would seem that Washington believes that Pakistan's military intelligence establishment, including the ISI, was sheltering bin Laden. The ISI was accused as recently as last week by the top US military official Admiral Mike Mullen of having terrorist links, and named as a terrorist support entity by US officials, according to the Guantanamo cables.
Lending credence to the charges is the fact that US forces homed in on bin Laden in Abbottabad, which is a cantonment just 50 kms from Islamabad, where the Pakistani military has a strong presence. The place where bin Laden was killed is only kilometers from the Kakul military academy, where many Pakistani military elites, including some of its ISI cadres, graduate from.
While US officials are tightlipped about precise details, analysts are trying to figure out whether the compound that sheltered bin Laden was an ISI safehouse. There is also speculation as to whether Hillary Clinton was referring to this when she made her pointed remarks last May.
US officials have said for years that they believed bin Laden escaped to Pakistan after the American bombing campaign in Afghanistan. But Pakistani officials, including its former military ruler Pervez Musharraf, insisted that he was in Afghanistan, even as Afghan officials would angrily refute it and say he is in Pakistan. In the end, the Americans and Afghans were right on the money.
Bin Laden was found at luxurious Pak compound with youngest wife
WASHINGTON: US forces finally found  al-Qaida  leader Osama  bin Laden not in the rugged mountains of Afghanistan's border, but  in a million-dollar compound in an upscale suburb of Pakistan's capital,  with his youngest wife, US officials said early on Monday. 
They were led to the fortress-like three-story building after more than  four years tracking one of bin Laden's most trusted couriers, whom U.S.  officials said was identified by men captured after the Sept. 11, 2001  attacks. 
"Detainees also identified this man as one of the few  al-Qaida couriers trusted by bin Laden. They indicated he might be  living with or protected by bin Laden," a senior administration official  said in a briefing for reporters. 
Bin Laden was finally found  -- more than 9-1/2 years after the 2001 attacks on the  United  States -- after authorities discovered in August 2010 that the  courier lived with his brother and their families in an unusual and  extremely high-security building, officials said. 
"When we saw  the compound where the brothers lived, we were shocked by what we saw:  an extraordinarily unique compound," a senior administration official  said. 
"The bottom line of our collection and our analysis was  that we had high confidence that the compound harbored a high-value  terrorist target. The experts who worked this issue for years assessed  that there was a strong probability that the terrorist who was hiding  there was Osama bin Laden," another administration official said. 
The home is in Abbotabad, a town about 35 miles (60 km) north of  Islamabad,  that is relatively affluent and home to many retired members of  Pakistan's military. 
The building, about eight times the size  of other nearby houses, sat on a large plot of land that was relatively  secluded when it was built in 2005. When it was constructed, it was on  the outskirts of Abbotabad's center, at the end of a dirt road, but some  other homes have been built nearby in the six years since it went up,  officials said. 
WALLS TOPPED WITH BARBED WIRE Intense security  measures included 12- to 18-foot (3.6 meters to 5.5 meters) outer walls  topped with barbed wire and internal walls that sectioned off different  parts of the compound, officials said. Two security gates restricted  access, and residents burned their trash, rather than leaving it for  collection as did their neighbors, officials said. 
Few windows  of the three-story home faced the outside of the compound, and a terrace  had a seven-foot (2.1 meter) privacy wall, officials said. 
"It  is also noteworthy that the property is valued at approximately $1  million but has no telephone or Internet service connected to it," an  administration official said. "The brothers had no explainable source of  wealth." 
US analysts realized that a third family lived there  in addition to the two brothers, and the age and makeup of the third  family matched those of the relatives -- including his youngest wife --  they believed would be living with bin Laden. 
"Everything we  saw, the extremely elaborate operational security, the brothers'  background and their behavior and the location of the compound itself  was perfectly consistent with what our experts expected bin Laden's  hide-out to look like," another Obama administration official said. 
A small US team conducted a helicopter raid on the compound on Sunday  afternoon, officials said. After 40 minutes of fighting, bin Laden and  an adult son, one unidentified woman and two men -- identified as the  courier and his brother -- were dead, officials said, and Obama was  preparing a television address to the nation. 
Abbotabad is a  popular summer resort, located in a valley surrounded by green hills  near Pakistani Kashmir. Islamist militants, particularly those fighting  in Indian-controlled Kashmir, used to have training camps near the town.  
NIGHT RAID : That Killed OSAMA
PAKISTAN: Al-Qaida leader   Osama  bin Laden was hiding out in a mansion near a Pakistani military  training academy and less than two hours' drive from  Islamabad  when he was killed in a dramatic CIA-led operation involving helicopters  and ground troops on Sunday night. 
The revelations that bin Laden was sheltering inside Pakistan is likely to ratchet up pressure on Islamabad.
The country's arch-rival, India, was quick to comment, saying the news underlined its "concern that terrorists belonging to different organisations find sanctuary in Pakistan".
A Reuter's photographer in the valley town of Abbotabad north of Islamabad said police had blocked the road leading to the area where the night-time raid at a huge compound took place.
"After midnight, a large number of commandos encircled the compound. Three helicopters were hovering overhead. All of a sudden there was firing towards the helicopters from the ground," said Nasir Khan, a resident of the town.
"There was intense firing and then I saw one of the helicopters falling down," said Khan, who had watched the dramatic scene unfold from his rooftop.
Senior Pakistani security officials said the operation, carried out at around 1:30 a.m., involved both helicopters and ground troops.
A Pakistani military helicopter crashed near Abbotabad on Sunday night, killing one and wounding two, according to local media. It was unclear if the crash was related to bin Laden's death, but witnesses reported gunshots and heavy firing before one of two low-flying helicopters crashed near the military academy.
Express 24/7 television showed an image of what it said was bin Laden shot in the head, his mouth pulled back in a grimace.
Pakistan Faces Awkward Questions
Bin Laden was the mastermind of the Sept 11, 2001 attacks that killed almost 3,000 people and put the United States on a decade-long war footing.
The fact bin Laden was apparently living in relative luxury not far from Islamabad could pose awkward questions for Pakistan.
Just 10 days ago Pakistan's army chief addressed army cadets at the academy near where bin Laden was killed, saying the country's military had broken the back of militants linked to al Qaeda and the Taliban.
"For some time there will be a lot of tension between Washington and Islamabad because bin Laden seems to have been living here close to Islamabad," said Imtiaz Gul, a security analyst.
"If the ISI had known then somebody within the ISI must have leaked this information," Gul said, referring to the Pakistani intelligence agency. "Pakistan will have to do a lot of damage control because the Americans have been reporting he is in Pakistan ... this is a serious blow to the credibility of Pakistan."
However, defence analyst and former general Talat Masood said the fact bin Laden was killed in a joint operation would limit the damage to Pakistan's image "There should be a sigh of relief because this will take some pressure off of Pakistan," said defence analyst and former general Talat Masood. "Pakistan most probably has contributed to this, and Pakistan can take some credit for this -- being such an iconic figure, it's a great achievement."
Abbotabad is a popular summer resort, located in a valley surrounded by green hills near Pakistani Kashmir. Islamist militants, particularly those fighting in Indian-controlled Kashmir, used to have training camps near the town.
The revelations that bin Laden was sheltering inside Pakistan is likely to ratchet up pressure on Islamabad.
The country's arch-rival, India, was quick to comment, saying the news underlined its "concern that terrorists belonging to different organisations find sanctuary in Pakistan".
A Reuter's photographer in the valley town of Abbotabad north of Islamabad said police had blocked the road leading to the area where the night-time raid at a huge compound took place.
"After midnight, a large number of commandos encircled the compound. Three helicopters were hovering overhead. All of a sudden there was firing towards the helicopters from the ground," said Nasir Khan, a resident of the town.
"There was intense firing and then I saw one of the helicopters falling down," said Khan, who had watched the dramatic scene unfold from his rooftop.
Senior Pakistani security officials said the operation, carried out at around 1:30 a.m., involved both helicopters and ground troops.
A Pakistani military helicopter crashed near Abbotabad on Sunday night, killing one and wounding two, according to local media. It was unclear if the crash was related to bin Laden's death, but witnesses reported gunshots and heavy firing before one of two low-flying helicopters crashed near the military academy.
Express 24/7 television showed an image of what it said was bin Laden shot in the head, his mouth pulled back in a grimace.
Pakistan Faces Awkward Questions
Bin Laden was the mastermind of the Sept 11, 2001 attacks that killed almost 3,000 people and put the United States on a decade-long war footing.
The fact bin Laden was apparently living in relative luxury not far from Islamabad could pose awkward questions for Pakistan.
Just 10 days ago Pakistan's army chief addressed army cadets at the academy near where bin Laden was killed, saying the country's military had broken the back of militants linked to al Qaeda and the Taliban.
"For some time there will be a lot of tension between Washington and Islamabad because bin Laden seems to have been living here close to Islamabad," said Imtiaz Gul, a security analyst.
"If the ISI had known then somebody within the ISI must have leaked this information," Gul said, referring to the Pakistani intelligence agency. "Pakistan will have to do a lot of damage control because the Americans have been reporting he is in Pakistan ... this is a serious blow to the credibility of Pakistan."
However, defence analyst and former general Talat Masood said the fact bin Laden was killed in a joint operation would limit the damage to Pakistan's image "There should be a sigh of relief because this will take some pressure off of Pakistan," said defence analyst and former general Talat Masood. "Pakistan most probably has contributed to this, and Pakistan can take some credit for this -- being such an iconic figure, it's a great achievement."
Abbotabad is a popular summer resort, located in a valley surrounded by green hills near Pakistani Kashmir. Islamist militants, particularly those fighting in Indian-controlled Kashmir, used to have training camps near the town.
OSAMA BIN LADEN Killed In Shootout, OBAMA Says
Al Qaeda  leader Osama bin  Laden was killed  Sunday in a firefight  with U.S. forces in  Pakistan  and his  body was recovered,  President Barack  Obama said on Sunday. "Justice has been done," Obama  said in a dramatic, late-night White House speech announcing the  death of the elusive mastermind of the September 11 , 2001 , attacks  on New York and Washington that  killed nearly 3 ,000  people. It is was major accomplishment for  Obama and his national security  team and could give him a political boost as he seeks re-election in  2012. And it was at least a huge symbolic blow to al Qaeda, the militant  organization that has staged  bloody attacks in many western  and Arab countries cities and has  been the subject of a worldwide  campaign against it. Obama said U.S. forces led a  targeted operation that killed bin  Laden in Abbotabad north of  Islamabad. No Americans were  killed in the operation and they  took care to avoid civilian  casualties, he said. In Washington, thousands of  people gathered quickly outside  the White House, waving American  flags, cheering and chanting "USA,  USA, USA." Car drivers blew their  horns in celebration and people  streamed to Lafayette Park across  from the presidential mansion.  Police vehicles with their lights  flashing stood vigil. "I'm down here to witness the  history. My boyfriend is  commissioning as a Marine next  week. So I'm really proud of the  troops," Laura Vogler, a junior at  American University in Washington, said outside the White House. Many Americans had given up hope of ever finding bin Laden after he  vanished in the mountains of  eastern  Afghanistan  in late 2001  as U.S. and allied forces invaded  the country in response to the  September 11  attacks. Intelligence that originated last  August provided the clues that  eventually led to bin Laden's trail,  the president said. A U.S. official  said Obama gave the final order to pursue the operation last Friday  morning. "The United States has conducted  an operation that killed Osama bin Laden, the leader of al Qaeda and  a terrorist who is responsible for  the murder of thousands of men,  women and children," Obama said. A crowd gathered in Lafayette Park outside the White House erupted  in jubilation at the news. Hundreds of people waved flags, hugged and cheered. CAPTURED DEAD Former President George W. Bush,  who famously vowed to bring bin  Laden to justice "dead or alive" but never did, called the operation a " momentous achievement" after  Obama called him with the news. Martin Indyk, a former U.S.  assistant secretary of state for near eastern affairs, described bin  Laden's death as "a body blow" to  al Qaeda at a time when its  ideology was already being  undercut by the popular  revolutions in the Arab world. Statements of appreciation poured  in from both sides of Washington's  often divided political divide.  Republican Senator John McCain  declared, "I am overjoyed that we  finally got the world's top terrorist. " Said former President Bill Clinton: " I congratulate the president, the  national security team and the  members of our armed forces on  bringing Osama bin Laden to  justice after more than a decade of murderous al Qaeda attacks." Having the body may help  convince any doubters that bin  Laden is really dead. Bin Laden had been hunted since  he eluded U.S. soldiers and Afghan  militia forces in a large-scale  assault on the Tora Bora  mountains of Afghanistan close to  the Pakistan frontier in 2001. The trail quickly went cold after he  disappeared and many intelligence officials believed he had been  hiding in Pakistan. While in hiding, bin Laden had  taunted the West and advocated  his militant Islamist views in  videotapes spirited from his  hideaway. Besides September 11 , Washington has also linked bin Laden to a  string of attacks -- including the  1998  bombings of American  embassies in Kenya and Tanzania  and the 2000  bombing of the  warship USS Cole in  Yemen .
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
 

 







